Differential D52777

packages: Add an "optional" set
ClosedPublic
Actions

Authored by ivy on Sep 28 2025, 10:57 PM.

Tags

None

Referenced Files

	Unknown Object (File)
	Sun, Jan 25, 12:25 AM

	Unknown Object (File)
	Tue, Jan 6, 6:00 PM

	Unknown Object (File)
	Dec 20 2025, 5:05 AM

	Unknown Object (File)
	Dec 18 2025, 2:28 AM

	Unknown Object (File)
	Dec 14 2025, 4:53 PM

	Unknown Object (File)
	Dec 14 2025, 2:15 PM

	Unknown Object (File)
	Dec 13 2025, 10:58 PM

	Unknown Object (File)
	Dec 12 2025, 9:19 PM

View All 40 Files

Subscribers

Details

Reviewers

imp
gnn
cperciva
bapt

Group Reviewers

pkgbase
releng

Commits

rG7082b85f03f7: packages: Add an "optional" set
rGeaecc9551ae4: packages: Add an "optional" set

Summary

This is everything in "base" but without compilers. This means we
have sets to support four basic workloads:

"minimal" for a small installation where the user intends to add other packages by hand.

"optional" for a complete installation on a production system which does not need to compile software.

"devel", which can be added to either minimal or optional when compilers are required.

"base" for a complete installation, including compilers, for users who don't want to interact with pkgbase and just want the complete system installed like it was before.

This is probably the last set want to add; any further metapackages
would be better treated as "task" packages intended to target one
specific workload.

Diff Detail

Repository

rG FreeBSD src repository

Lint

Lint Not Applicable

Unit

Tests Not Applicable

Event Timeline

ivy created this revision.Sep 28 2025, 10:57 PM

Herald added a reviewer: gnn. · View Herald TranscriptSep 28 2025, 10:57 PM

Herald added subscribers: jrtc27, dab. · View Herald Transcript

ivy requested review of this revision.Sep 28 2025, 10:57 PM

Harbormaster completed remote builds in B67382: Diff 163005.Sep 28 2025, 10:57 PM

@dch: you should be able to use this for the "notoolchain" OCI image.

cperciva added a subscriber: cperciva.Sep 28 2025, 11:05 PM

cperciva added inline comments.

release/packages/sets/optional-jail-dbg.ucl
19	Should this say "for jails"?

add a description for bsdinstall

Harbormaster completed remote builds in B67383: Diff 163006.Sep 28 2025, 11:05 PM

fix the optional-jail-dbg comment

Harbormaster completed remote builds in B67384: Diff 163007.Sep 28 2025, 11:08 PM

ivy marked an inline comment as done.Sep 28 2025, 11:08 PM

ivy added inline comments.

release/packages/sets/optional-jail-dbg.ucl
19	probably yes, fixed!

LGTM!

This revision is now accepted and ready to land.Sep 28 2025, 11:12 PM

bapt accepted this revision.Sep 29 2025, 8:37 AM

Closed by commit rGeaecc9551ae4: packages: Add an "optional" set (authored by ivy). · Explain WhySep 29 2025, 9:56 PM

This revision was automatically updated to reflect the committed changes.

ivy marked an inline comment as done.

ivy added a commit: rGeaecc9551ae4: packages: Add an "optional" set.

ivy added a commit: rG7082b85f03f7: packages: Add an "optional" set.Oct 1 2025, 12:36 PM

Revision Contents
Changeset List

Path

Size

release/

packages/

sets/

6 lines

10 lines

	optional-dbg.ucl
	base.ucl

13 lines

	optional-jail-dbg.ucl
	base.ucl

13 lines

	optional-jail.ucl
	base-jail.ucl

11 lines

	optional.ucl
	base.ucl

9 lines

ucl/

2 lines

4 lines

4 lines

2 lines

2 lines

2 lines

2 lines

blocklist-all.ucl

2 lines

bluetooth-all.ucl

4 lines

bsdconfig-all.ucl

2 lines

bsdinstall-all.ucl

2 lines

2 lines

ccdconfig-all.ucl

4 lines

console-tools-all.ucl

4 lines

2 lines

4 lines

cxgbe-tools-all.ucl

4 lines

2 lines

4 lines

4 lines

2 lines

examples-all.ucl

2 lines

4 lines

2 lines

2 lines

4 lines

2 lines

4 lines

hostapd-all.ucl

4 lines

2 lines

2 lines

2 lines

4 lines

2 lines

kerberos-all.ucl

2 lines

kerberos-kdc-all.ucl

2 lines

2 lines

2 lines

libarchive-all.ucl

2 lines

libbegemot-all.ucl

2 lines

libblocksruntime-all.ucl

2 lines

libbsdstat-all.ucl

2 lines

2 lines

libcasper-all.ucl

2 lines

libcompat-all.ucl

2 lines

libcompiler_rt-all.ucl

2 lines

libcuse-all.ucl

2 lines

libdwarf-all.ucl

2 lines

libevent1-all.ucl

2 lines

libexecinfo-all.ucl

2 lines

2 lines

libldns-all.ucl

2 lines

liblzma-all.ucl

2 lines

libmagic-all.ucl

2 lines

libmilter-all.ucl

2 lines

libpathconv-all.ucl

2 lines

librpcsec_gss-all.ucl

2 lines

2 lines

2 lines

libsqlite3-all.ucl

2 lines

libstdbuf-all.ucl

2 lines

libstdthreads-all.ucl

2 lines

libthread_db-all.ucl

2 lines

2 lines

2 lines

libvmmapi-all.ucl

2 lines

2 lines

libyaml-all.ucl

2 lines

2 lines

mlx-tools-all.ucl

4 lines

2 lines

2 lines

2 lines

2 lines

nvme-tools-all.ucl

4 lines

openssl-all.ucl

2 lines

2 lines

2 lines

quotacheck-all.ucl

2 lines

2 lines

2 lines

2 lines

sendmail-all.ucl

2 lines

smbutils-all.ucl

4 lines

2 lines

syscons-data-all.ucl

4 lines

2 lines

2 lines

unbound-all.ucl

2 lines

2 lines

usr.sbin/

bsdinstall/

scripts/

3 lines

Diff 163039

release/packages/sets/base-jail.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/sets/base.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/sets/optional-dbg.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/sets/optional-jail-dbg.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/sets/optional-jail.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/sets/optional.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/acct-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/acpi-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/apm-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/atf-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/audit-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/autofs-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/bhyve-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/blocklist-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/bluetooth-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/bsdconfig-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/bsdinstall-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/bsnmp-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/ccdconfig-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/console-tools-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/csh-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/ctl-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/cxgbe-tools-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/dma-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/dtrace-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/dwatch-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/ee-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/examples-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/fd-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/ftp-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/games-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/ggate-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/gssd-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/hast-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/hostapd-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/inetd-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/ipf-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/ipfw-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/iscsi-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/jail-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/kerberos-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/kerberos-kdc-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/kyua-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/lib9p-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/libarchive-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/libbegemot-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/libblocksruntime-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/libbsdstat-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/libbsm-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/libcasper-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/libcompat-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/libcompiler_rt-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/libcuse-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/libdwarf-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/libevent1-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/libexecinfo-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/libipt-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/libldns-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/liblzma-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/libmagic-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/libmilter-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/libpathconv-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/librpcsec_gss-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/librss-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/libsdp-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/libsqlite3-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/libstdbuf-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/libstdthreads-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/libthread_db-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/libucl-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/libvgl-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/libvmmapi-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/liby-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/libyaml-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/lp-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/mlx-tools-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/natd-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/netmap-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/nfs-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/ntp-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/nvme-tools-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/openssl-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/pf-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/pmc-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/quotacheck-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/rcmds-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/rdma-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/rip-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/sendmail-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/smbutils-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/ssh-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/syscons-data-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/tcpd-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/telnet-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/unbound-all.ucl

Loading...

release/packages/ucl/yp-all.ucl

Loading...

usr.sbin/bsdinstall/scripts/pkgbase.in

Loading...