Details
- Reviewers
fernape pauamma_gundo.com - Group Reviewers
docs - Commits
- R9:08dd1185b440: Porter Handbook: Update documentation on porting Haskell programs.
Diff Detail
- Repository
- R9 FreeBSD doc repository
- Lint
Lint Not Applicable - Unit
Tests Not Applicable
Event Timeline
Thanks!
Very good job and update for the PHB!
documentation/content/en/books/porters-handbook/special/_index.adoc | ||
---|---|---|
985 | This minimal Makefile fetches... (remove _allows us_). | |
998 | Either full stop after ${WRKSRC} or link the two sentences with: Now _that_ we have...., we can use... | |
1024–1025 | Revisions can affect [.filename]#.cabal# files _only (only at the end). Then full stop instead of _,_ ...files only_._ Note additional... | |
1047 | under _the_ share/${PORTNAME} directory... | |
1048 | ...define _the_ CABAL_WRAPPER_SCRIPTS knob... | |
1055 | Avoid contractions. Also simplify sentence. How about this? devel/hs-profiteur is a Haskell application that... | |
1103 | Now the port _will_ install | |
1107 | remove "," | |
1117 | Either The net-p2p/cardano-node _port_... or net-p2p/cardano-node is a extremely... I prefer the latter :-) Also, try to avoid the use of "we", "you" , etc. How about: Reading its cabal.project we will find... ---> In its cabal.project there are a lot of blocks like this: | |
1129 | Either ...by cabal during... I prefer the former. | |
1130 | Rephrasing: Unfortunately this makes use of the network after the fetch stage. This is disallow by the ports framework. | |
1131 | We have to arrange these sources in the ports Makefile ourselves ---> These sources need to be listed in the port's Makefile. | |
1132 | ... after _the_ usual... not only _the_ USE_CABAL knob... | |
1147 | Remove "," It might be useful to separate _the_ GH_TUPLE items coming from make-use-cabal _from_ the other ones to make it easy... | |
documentation/content/en/books/porters-handbook/uses/_index.adoc | ||
197 | ... the framework _will_ not try... | |
198 | ... _are_ present. | |
218 | ...value _corresponds_ to... | |
247 | s/Ports/ports. | |
248 | Unclosed _`_ quote at the end. |
A bunch of small nits. I'd also like someone who understands haskell porting to review for accuracy.
documentation/content/en/books/porters-handbook/special/_index.adoc | ||
---|---|---|
968–969 | Missed it earlier. | |
1024–1025 | One sentence per line. | |
1047 | ||
1116 | "a very complex" or "an extremely complex" | |
documentation/content/en/books/porters-handbook/uses/_index.adoc | ||
195 | Or maybe "If hpack is given" | |
197 | As above. | |
198 | I still disagree with fernape. | |
244 | ||
248 | ||
249 | ||
250 |
LGTM.
Gleb please, would you hold a couple of days until @pauamma reviews this again or we call a timeout?
Thanks!
documentation/content/en/books/porters-handbook/uses/_index.adoc | ||
---|---|---|
198 |
Yes, I think you're right. Thanks! |