HomeFreeBSD

Eliminate lock order reversal in UFS when unmounting filesystems

Description

Eliminate lock order reversal in UFS when unmounting filesystems
with snapshots.

Each vnode has an embedded lock that controls access to its contents.
However vnodes describing a UFS snapshot all share a single snapshot
lock to coordinate their access and update. As part of mounting a
UFS filesystem with snapshots, each of the vnodes describing a
snapshot has its individual lock replaced with the snapshot lock.
When the filesystem is unmounted the vnode's original lock is
returned replacing the snapshot lock.

The lock order reversal happens because vnode locks must be acquired
before snapshot locks. When unmounting we must lock both the snapshot
lock and the vnode lock before swapping them so that the vnode will
be continuously locked during the swap. For each vnode representing
a snapshot, we must first acquire the snapshot lock to ensure
exclusive access to it and its original lock. We then face a lock
order reversal when we try to acquire the original vnode lock. The
problem is eliminated by doing a non-blocking exclusive lock on the
original lock which will always succeed since there are no users
of that lock.

Sponsored by: Netflix

Details

Provenance
mckusickAuthored on Jan 16 2021, 12:00 AM
Parents
R10:994e1f40f6db: lualoader: use floor division to get correct type
Branches
Unknown
Tags
Unknown